Phillies could have something in their favor for Game 2 against Pirates

The Philadelphia Phillies dropped yet another close one, falling 5–4 to the Pittsburgh Pirates in Game 1 of the series. It marked their seventh loss in the last eight games, with just one win during that stretch. But in Game 2, they could be looking at a potential opening—thanks to a familiar arm on the mound for Pittsburgh.

The Pirates will hand the ball to a veteran with 12 years of big-league experience. Andrew Heaney has pitched for the Marlins, Angels, Yankees, Dodgers, and most recently the Rangers—winning a World Series ring with Texas in 2023. He enters the matchup with a 4.39 career ERA.

Interestingly, the Pirates earned their Game 1 win behind David Bednar, who entered the night with an 0–4 record and no wins on the season. Now, they turn to a pitcher, who holds a 3–4 record and 3.39 ERA so far this year.

Who’s starting for the Pirates in Game 2?

According to MLB, Andrew Heaney is set to start for the Pirates in Game 2. He’s made 12 starts this season, with his most recent outing coming in a 6–4 loss to the Padres where he earned a no-decision. His last win came on May 21 against the Reds.

PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA – MAY 16: Andrew Heaney #45 of the Pittsburgh Pirates delivers a pitch against the Philadelphia Phillies in the first inning at Citizens Bank Park on May 16, 2025 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Heather Barry/Getty Images)

Why might the Phillies have the edge with Heaney?

It’s pretty straightforward—Heaney has struggled historically against the Phillies. He’s 0–2 in his career against them, with one no-decision earlier this season on May 16. His first two losses came back in 2014, and he’s faced them while with the Marlins, Rangers, and most recently the Pirates. His career ERA vs. the Phillies sits at 6.07.

SurveyIs it a guaranteed victory for the Phillies against Heaney?

Is it a guaranteed victory for the Phillies against Heaney?

In his most recent outing against Philadelphia, Heaney controlled the first five innings, allowing just one run in a game played at Citizens Bank Park. But once he exited, the Pirates bullpen collapsed, surrendering seven runs as the Phillies pulled away for an 8–4 win.